Public health
Originally published

Author’s note: I wrote this in 2020, in the days after George Floyd was killed, while protests filled the streets and our TV screens. I am republishing it in 2026, lightly edited, because the argument it answers still comes up every time, and the answer has not changed.
I want to address something I have never understood: why people feel inclined to bring up “black-on-black violence” whenever police brutality comes up. The two are unrelated. As a scientist with an interest in public health, I went to the data to understand it fully, and I want to walk through it with y’all.
What the data says about police killings
Violence in the United States is a public health concern. In response, the CDC created the National Violent Death Reporting System in 2002, three years after the Columbine school shooting. I’m not sure whether that horrific event prompted the system’s development, but I will come back to school shootings later.
Death by law enforcement’s use of lethal force is one of the categories the system tracks. It has been hard to track well, because what a police department documents can differ from what a medical examiner reports (a homicide, for example). Even with those inconsistencies, the data is glaring: Black Americans are disproportionately killed by police. They are 2.8 times more likely than white Americans to be killed by police, and more likely to be unarmed when it happens.
2015 was a particularly harrowing year. Young Black men were nine times more likely than other Americans to be killed by police officers. Black males between the ages of 15 and 34 make up only 2% of the U.S. population, yet they accounted for more than 15% of all deaths logged that year, a rate five times higher than white men of the same age.
To jog your memory, Freddie Gray and Walter Scott were two of the deaths that made national headlines in 2015. Many more people were killed whose names we will never know, because no one was recording.
Gray died after his neck was broken in the back of a police transport van. He had been restrained with handcuffs and leg irons, but not a seat belt. Six officers were charged in his death. None were convicted.
Scott was running away on foot from a traffic stop in North Charleston, S.C. He was unarmed and posed no threat to the officer, Michael Slager, who fired eight shots. Five of them hit Scott. Slager was sentenced to 20 years in prison. I guess shooting a man in the back as he runs away is just too egregious to ignore.
That is the quick and dirty version of police brutality in the U.S. Anyone with eyes and a conscience knows the reality, even without the data. As a reminder, police are supposed to protect the public, and we pay them with our tax dollars to do so. This data shows a glaring abuse of power. And it doesn’t even account for the thousands of people who are injured, or falsely accused on trumped-up charges.
Are there good police? Without a doubt. I know many of them. Are there bad police? ABSOLUTELY. And a lot of them are showing their whole ass on TV during these protests.
The truth about “black-on-black crime”
Now, according to FBI homicide data from 2013, 90% of Black Americans who were murdered were killed by another Black American. And 83% of white Americans who were murdered were killed by another white American. The numbers are nearly identical, because people tend to kill the people they live around. That is why the term “black-on-black crime” is so annoying. Nobody says “white-on-white crime.”
I do want to talk about that slight difference in percentage, though, because it has a history.
The association of Blackness with criminality goes back to the post-Reconstruction era. As Black Americans began leaving the South for opportunity in Northern cities, and to escape violence at the hands of racist Southerners, white social scientists used crime statistics to tie Blackness to criminality. It worked. Decades of that insinuation helped fuel the white flight of the mid-20th century, when white families left the cities rather than live among Black neighbors. Chicago and many other cities show the result: segregated inner cities.
Poverty escalated as economic opportunity for Black residents shrank. Unemployment rose, school quality fell, and inadequate housing became the norm. Gangs and drug dealers flourish in that kind of environment. These neighborhoods then became overpoliced and underpoliced at the SAME DAMN TIME. Black folks, who had been abused by police ever since the abolition of slavery, could now be brutalized in a segregated echo chamber. And when Black residents, the vast majority of them not criminals, called the police for help, they got inadequate protection and less investigative time and effort.
Law-abiding Black Americans were trapped in a hellhole, victimized by criminal neighbors AND by police.
Black people are not inherently more violent than any other race, and the term “black-on-black crime” needs to be retired. Bringing it up when the subject is police abuse of power is callous, ignorant, and quite frankly IRRELEVANT. I would expect people to see how much victimization has occurred.
What school shootings show us
Data on school shootings was harder to find. From what I did find, mass shootings happen mostly at majority-white schools and are typically carried out by young white males while school is in session. Shootings at predominantly white schools also have more casualties, three on average, which is twice the average at predominantly Black and Hispanic schools.
To be clear, I don’t bring this up as tit-for-tat. The common denominator is that, Black or white, the people killed in all of these scenarios are VICTIMS, and they do not deserve blame. When a school shooting happens, Americans don’t blame the community it happened in. We don’t point fingers. We mourn as a nation and we brainstorm solutions: gun control measures, mental health treatment, an overhaul of video games, and so on.
Black Americans deserve the SAME GRACE.
Sources
FBI: Expanded Homicide Data Table 6, 2013
U.S. Census Bureau: QuickFacts
CityLab: The Origins of the Phrase “Black-on-Black Crime”
Harvard Kennedy School: Police and Public Discourse on “Black-on-Black” Violence
CDC: National Violent Death Reporting System resources
This article is for education and is not personal medical advice. Please talk with your own clinician about your situation.